Interaction as a Key Term

Modelling Spheres of Intercation

Oliver Nakoinz
MOSAIC Summer School 2016

Interaction as a key term

  • Introduction
  • Facets of interaction
  • Interaction in different disciplines
  • Modells
  • Quantitative analysis
  • Theory and method of interaction modelling
  • Approaches of interaction analysis
  • Case studies
  • Summary

Why interaction?

Interaction as a key term

Interaction

  • Trade
  • Conflict
  • Transportation
paintings from S. Bening, E. Hünten, C. Monet source: Wikipedia

Interaction

Purpose of interaction

  • allows to join forces to reach certain targets
  • changes (extends/reduces) the individual capability

What is interaction?

Defining interaction

Definition 1

  • Interaction is the joint action of at least two interaction partners.

Definition 2

  • Spatial Interaction connects different locations by the means of moving people, goods or knowledge between the locations.

Definition 3

  • Communication is the exchange of information.

Facets of interaction

  • culture
  • mobility and transport
  • centrality
  • trade and exchange
  • conflicts
  • social structure
  • territoriality and borders
  • collective identities

Conflict and cooperation

Conflict

  • contradicting goals of the two interaction partners
  • limitation of the other’s capability
  • hamper the other’s efforts Cooperation
  • similar goals of the two interaction partners
  • extension of the other’s capability
  • supporting the other’s efforts

Interaction

Power and Leverage

Traditional history is about events, when people interact. It is about gaining and applying power and influencing and controlling the behaviour of other people using different means.

Battle of Königsgrätz, painting by E. Hünten

Interaction

Social structures

Social structures are a kind of infrastructure of effective interaction. Social structures are defining the acceptable and unacceptable kinds of interaction. The negotiation of social status is a process of interaction.

Nationalversammlung Frankfurt 1848, painting by L. v. Elliott

Interaction

Interaction

Interaction supports the fulfilment of needs and to overcome shortages by changing the distribution of commodities and conducting services:

  • trade
  • division of labour
  • services
Renfrew 1975

Interaction

Innovations

Interaction supports innovations by

  • enabling the required knowledge base by the collaboration of developers
  • distributing the innovation
M. Lomonosow, painting by I. Feodorov

Interaction

Transportation

If people are at different places, they need means of transportation or telecommunication for conducting interaction. It is required to move people, commodities or ideas/knowledge. The means of transportation and the transportation infrastructure is at the same time enabling and restricting interaction. The system of transportation:

  • is mapping the structure of the system of interaction
  • is canalizing the interaction
  • is influenced by the system of interaction (although, there is a certain inertia)

Interaction

Daily live and culture

Interaction is an essential part of the daily live. Every contact to another individual represents a process of interaction, even if the purpose is not clear.

painting by P. A. Renoir

Interaction

Daily live and culture

If a certain behaviour becomes a custom and is shared with others, we call it culture. Since interaction causes common standardisations, culture is a kind of effect of interaction.

Definition 4

  • Culture covers standardisations which are valid in collectives.
Hansen 2003, 39

Interaction

Culture

  • Formal and abstract definition which covers most other
  • Spatial archaeological cultures as special case
  • Applicable in archaeology

Cultures are mapping interaction structures

Advantages of interaction as concept

  • interaction is the driving force of soical, economic, cultural and historical processes and present in many aspects of daily live
  • interaction is very abstract and is able to cover different aspects of human behaviour hence
  • we need not to start our investigation with distinguishing different kinds of interaction
  • interaction is a key term for different geographical and archaeological topics
  • we can easily connect to other disciplines

Interaction in different disciplines

  • physics: gravity law, Hamada-Johnston-Potential
  • human-ecology: human-environment interaction
  • sociology: Parson theory of roles, Blumer theory of symbolic interaction
  • psychology: interaction in diades theory, dialog theory
  • ethnology: Malinowskies theory of gift exchange
  • economy: Polanyis market theory
  • geography: Ravensteins theory of migration, Wilsons theory entropy of traffic, Christallers theory of central places

Interaction in different disciplines

Physics

  • Newton
  • gravity law \[I = \frac{m_1*m_2}{d^k} \]

Interaction in different disciplines

Ethnology

  • Malinowski
  • Kula ring
  • gift exchange

Interaction in different disciplines

Economy

  • Polanyi
  • market, redistribution, reciprocity

Interaction in different disciplines

Sociology

  • Blumer
  • symbolic interaction

Interaction in different disciplines

Psychology

  • Garrod/Pickering
  • alignment in dialogues

Interaction in different disciplines

Geography

  • Christaller
  • central place theory

Centrality as example

Definition 5

Centrality is the relative surplus of meaning due to fulfilling central functions for the surrounding area.

Christaller 1933, 26-27

Definition 6

Centrality is the relative concentration of interaction.

Nakoinz 2012

Vector of centrality

  • I Intensity of Interaction
  • R Reach of Interaction
  • H Level of Hierarchy
  • K Control of Interaction

Interaction

What is a model?

Definitions of model

Definition 7

A possible realisation in which all valid sentences of a theory T are satisfied is called a model of T.

Alfred Tarski 1953

Definitions of model

A model is characterised by:

  • mapping
  • reduction
  • pragmatism
Herbert Stachowiak 1973

Definition 8

\(O_1\) and \(O_2\) are objects and \(O_2\) is a model of \(O_1\) for \(k\) in the time interval \(t\) regarding a certain purpose \(Z\) if in \(t k\):

  • is L-rational
  • performs a description \(P_1\) of \(O_1\)
  • performs a description \(P_2\) of \(O_2\)
  • performs a mapping of \(P_1\) on \(P_2\)
  • performs a transcoding of \(P_1\) in \(P_2\)
  • performs the substitution of \(O_1\) by \(O_2\)
  • performs certain operations on \(O_2\) in order to fulfil the purpose \(Z\) and which transfer \(O_2\) to \(O_2*\)
  • performs a description \(P_2*\) of \(O_2*\)
  • performs the reverse mapping of \(P_2*\) on \(P_1*\)
  • accepts \(P_1*\) as the description of \(O_1*\)
  • accepts the substitution of \(O_1*\) by \(O_2*\)
  • performs a recoding of P1 in P2 regarding \(P_1*\) and \(P_2*\)
Herbert Stachowiak 1973

Definitions of model

Definition 9

A model is a simplified mapping used for a certain purpose.

Definitions of model

Definition 10

  • is a structure of a theory;
  • complies with a set of hypotheses; and
  • is not a simple statement.
Wolfgang Balzer 2009

Definitions of model

Definition 11

A model is an iconic sign.

Björn Kralemann, Claas Lattmann 2012

Definitions of model

Definition 12

A model is an artefact, used for a certain purpose by a specific community. The model is analogue to the original. A model has certain methods for development and usage and is based on certain theories and assumptions.

Bernd Thalheim 2015

Definitions of model

Cambridge

Peter Haggett

  • New Geography
  • Locational Analysis in Human Geography, 1965
  • Models in Geography, 1967, together with R. Chorley

David L. Clarke

  • New Archaeology
  • Analytical Archaeology 1968
  • Models in Archaeology, 1972

Definitions of model

Definition 13

A model is characterised by:

  • comprehensiveness;
  • predictivness;
  • efficiency; and
  • accuracy.
David L. Clarke 1972

Definitions of model

Definition 14

A model is a simplified and intelligible picture of the world.

Richard Chorley, Peter Haggett 1967

Which types of models can you distinguish?

Interaction as a key term

Interaction as a key term

Model classification | SQM-Classification

Kai Velten 2009
S - system
  • physical - conceptual
  • natural - technical
  • stochastic - deterministic
  • continuous - discrete
  • dimension
  • field of application
Q - objectives
  • phenomenological - mechanistic
  • stationary -instationary
  • lumped - distributed
  • direct - inverse
  • research - management
  • speculation - design
  • scale
M - mathematical structure
  • linear - non-linear
  • analytical - numerical
  • autonomous - non-autonomous
  • continuous - discrete
  • differential equations
  • integral equations
  • algebraic equations

Interaction as a key term

Examples of modelling interaction

Diffusion model

\[\frac{\delta p}{\delta t} = k \frac{\delta^2p}{\delta x^2} + mp(1-p)\]

Wave of advance (Fisher 1937):

  • \(p\) is the frequency of a mutantgene
  • \(t\) the time
  • \(x\) a spatial coordinate
  • \(m\) the intensity of selection
  • \(k\) the diffusion coefficient

Examples of modelling interaction

Pred predator

\[\frac{\delta x}{\delta t} = ayx - bx\]

\[\frac{\delta y}{\delta t} = cy - dxy\]

Lotka-Volterra equations (Lotka 1925; Volterra 1926):

  • \(x\) population of the predator
  • \(y\) population of its prey

Examples of modelling interaction

Voronoi graph

  • tesselation
  • influence of centre depends on distance
  • distance to centre is equal for all points of the border
  • \(a = b\)
  • territory is optimized for transportation

Examples of modelling interaction

Voronoi graph

geographical space

  • economical space (least cost distance)
  • cultural space

Examples of modelling interaction

Voronoi graph

  • geographical space

economical space (least cost distance)

  • cultural space

Examples of modelling interaction

Voronoi graph

  • geographical space
  • economical space (least cost distance)

cultural space

Space

Disciplinary spaces

A metrical space is spanned by a metric, which defines distances.

  • A social space is constructed by social distances.
  • An economic space is constructed by economic-distances.
  • A cultural space is constructed by cultural distances.
  • A geographic space is constructed by geodetic distances.

Interaction as a key term

Fetter modell

  • weighted Voronoi-graph
  • market areas on the basis of costs of transport
  • Fetter 1924; Haggett 2004
Frank A. Fetter (1863-1949)

Interaction as a key term

X-tent

  • weighted Voronoi-graph
  • Renfrew & Level 1979

Interaction as a key term

Weighted Voroni

  • \(\alpha_s\) static additive weight
  • \(\alpha_d\) dynamic additive weight
  • \(\gamma_s\) static multiplicative weight
  • \(\gamma_d\) dynamic multiplicative weight
  • \(t_\alpha\) 1=dynamic additive
  • \(t_\gamma\) 1=dynamic multiplicativeweight
  • \(\psi\) distance manipulating function
  • \(x_z\) x reference point
  • \(y_z\) y reference point
  • \(x_p\) x point in question
  • \(y_p\) y point in question

\[ \Phi = \alpha - \gamma\psi(\delta) \]

\[ \alpha = \alpha_s(t_\alpha \alpha_d + \mid t_\alpha -1 \mid)\]

\[ \gamma = \gamma_s(t_\gamma \gamma_d + \mid t_\gamma -1 \mid)\]

\[ \delta = \left(\sqrt{(x_z - x_p)^2 + (y_z -y_p)}\right)\]

Interaction as a key term

Weighted Voronoi

  • Princely seats
  • weighted Voronoi graphs
  • weighted with number of rich graves
  • Software: Grass
  • today a Grass-addon is available: r.xtent

Interaction as a key term

Weighted Voronoi

  • Princely seats
  • weighted Voronoi graphs
  • weighted with number of rich graves and wagon graves
  • least cost distance
  • Software: R

Why modelling interaction?

Interaction as a key term

Quantitative analysis

  1. Problem: Put your question.
  2. Theory: Which theoretical frame is adequate for solving the problem?
  3. Data: Which data can be used for solving the problem? Are they available as database etc.? How can you access the data?
  4. Method: Which methods can solve the problem? Learn the methods!
  5. Tool: Learn the tools to apply the methods.
  1. Check, validate and interpret the results: plausible? significant?
?
ODTM-Balance
Objective - Data - Theory - Method

Interaction as a key term

Quantitative analysis

  1. Problem: Put your question.
  2. Theory: Which theoretical frame is adequate for solving the problem?
  3. Data: Which data can be used for solving the problem? Are they available as database etc.? How can you access the data?
  4. Method: Which methods can solve the problem? Learn the methods!
  5. Tool: Learn the tools to apply the methods.
  1. Check, validate and interpret the results: plausible? significant?

Theories

Definition 15

A theory is an abstract concept of the relationship of facts.

Theories

Type a

Meta theories

  • philosophy
  • research strategies
  • epistemology

Low level theories

  • mathematics
  • database development
  • logic
  • theory of cluster analysis

Type b

High level theories

  • social theories
  • human behaviour and cognition theories
  • chronological systems

Middle range theories

  • formation processes
  • source criticism
  • theory of typology

Interaction as a key term

Quantitative analysis

  1. Problem: Put your question.
  2. Theory: Which theoretical frame is adequate for solving the problem?
  3. Data: Which data can be used for solving the problem? Are they available as database etc.? How can you access the data?
  4. Method: Which methods can solve the problem? Learn the methods!
  5. Tool: Learn the tools to apply the methods.
  1. Check, validate and interpret the results: plausible? significant?

Data

Interaction as a key term

Quantitative analysis

  1. Problem: Put your question.
  2. Theory: Which theoretical frame is adequate for solving the problem?
  3. Data: Which data can be used for solving the problem? Are they available as database etc.? How can you access the data?
  4. Method: Which methods can solve the problem? Learn the methods!
  5. Tool: Learn the tools to apply the methods.
  1. Check, validate and interpret the results: plausible? significant?

Interaction as a key term

Quantitative analysis

  1. Problem: Put your question.
  2. Theory: Which theoretical frame is adequate for solving the problem?
  3. Data: Which data can be used for solving the problem? Are they available as database etc.? How can you access the data?
  4. Method: Which methods can solve the problem? Learn the methods!
  5. Tool: Learn the tools to apply the methods.
  1. Check, validate and interpret the results: plausible? significant?

Interaction as a key term

Quantitative analysis

  1. Problem: Put your question.
  2. Theory: Which theoretical frame is adequate for solving the problem?
  3. Data: Which data can be used for solving the problem? Are they available as database etc.? How can you access the data?
  4. Method: Which methods can solve the problem? Learn the methods!
  5. Tool: Learn the tools to apply the methods.
  1. Interpret, check and validate the results. plausible? significant?
Can it be?
Is it significant?
What does it mean?

Research process

Research process

Interaction as a key term

Types of interaction models

  • conceptual models
  • affirmative models
  • quantitative relationship models
  • system models
  • models of complex systems

Interaction as a key term

Considerations

  • which elements do we investigate?
  • which parameters are important?
  • how are the parameters related?
  • how are the elements and parameters establishing systems?
  • how can we compare empirical and theoretical models?
  • what do the results tell us?

Which factors and parameters of interaction do you know?

Interaction as a key term

distance

  • geographical distance
  • social distance
  • cultural distance
  • economical distance

point features

  • size
  • population

How can we measure interaction?

Which measures of and proxies for interaction do you know?

Measures

point distribution

  • minimal requirements
  • measures general degree of interaction in a region

number of exchanged objects

  • small data
  • can deal with individual interactions

inverse cultural distance

  • robust because of extensive data
  • can deal with short range interaction
  • can measure different types of interaction

Interaction as a key term

NN-Distance

  • Is there interaction between the points?
  • Test on complete spatial randomness
  • regular - random - clustered

Interaction as a key term

Imports

  • connecting a site to a provenience region
  • individual interactions can be traced

Interaction as a key term

Cultural distance

  • interactions are producing cultural similarities
  • difference in material culture
  • statistical level of interaction between sites or regions

Interaction as a key term

Cultural distance

  • topography of cultural similarities
  • territories of cultural similarities
  • cultural areas
  • interaction models

Interaction as a key term

Theoretical Models

  • Interaction decreases with distance. Distance decay functions can quantify the decrease.

\[I = \frac{k}{d^i}\]

Interaction as a key term

Gravity models

  • involve properties of the interaction partners
  • based on an analogy from physics
  • population, settlement size, ...
  • can be used to produce distance decay functions/fall off curves, which consider population

Interaction as a key term

Distance diagram (dd)

  • different view-points
  • different focus-points
  • cultural distance as an inverse interaction proxy
Viewpoint fixed vocus selected focus all foucused
fixed viewpoint dd1 fixed profile dd, similarity profiles dd2 fixed sector dd dd3 fixed multi-focal dd, fall-off curve
selected viewpoints dd4 selected profile dd dd5 selected secotr dd dd6 selected multi-focal dd
all viewpointsdd7 aggregated profile dd dd8 aggregated sector dd dd9 aggregated multi-focal dd, variogram

Interaction as a key term

Definition 16 Interaction models plot intensity of interaction over distance.

  • cultural distances as inverse proxys of interaction
  • different metrics and weightings
Nakoinz 2013

Interaction as a key term

Interaction model

  • fixed starting point
  • fixed profile
  • ceramics
  • interaction friction at Black Forrest?

Interaction as a key term

Interaction model

  • from all points
  • to all points
  • fibulae and adornment
  • interaction threshold at 200 km?

Interaction as a key term

Modelling systems of transportation

  • is essential for modelling interaction
  • produces knowledge of significant parameters
  • the system of transportation provides
    • the structure of the interaction model and
    • economical distances by least cost modelling

Interaction as a key term

Modelling systems of transportation

  • empirical model based on the sites
  • theoretical least cost path model
  • the comparison of both models reveals the parameters of the routes

Interaction as a key term

Least Cost Path

  • calculated the most efficient path between \(A and B\)
Surface-Evans 2012

Interaction as a key term

What does ’least cost’ mean?

Which data are required/available?

Interaction as a key term | Least Cost Path

How to find the pathway?

  • costs for moving from one cell to the next one

Interaction as a key term | Least Cost Path

How to find the pathway?

  • costs for moving from one cell to the next one
  • searching for the next connection which produces minimal cumulated costs

Interaction as a key term | Least Cost Path

How to find the pathway?

  • costs for moving from one cell to the next one
  • searching for the next connection which produces minimal cumulated costs
  • going back the pathway along the connections, which me noted down

Interaction as a key term | Least Cost Path

How to find the pathway?

  • costs for moving from one cell to the next one
  • searching for the next connection which produces minimal cumulated costs
  • going back the pathway along the connections, which me noted down

Interaction as a key term

Agent based model

  • dynamic model of the exchange and settlement system

Interaction as a key term

Consider your own life

  • make a list of your interactions
  • which types of interactions can you distinguish?
  • which parameters are important?
  • which information would be archaeological available?

Interaction as a key term

Summary

  • interaction is a trans-disciplinary key term in many fields of research
  • interaction is an driver of historic, economic, social and cultural processes.
  • interaction is an abstract concept
  • different types of distances can be used
  • models of systems of interaction are based on simple interaction-distance relationships

Presentations